Smocks - Titan or Greys?

I'm thinking of getting a smock for the upcoming freezing and soaking (naturally) winter months. Any ideas? I had a waterproof Titan one for years but lost it. I heard the Greys ones are good

titan by a mile. i like that its not to thick and you can wear layers underneath and take off or put on as weather changes i can fold my smock and put in box until it rains and no zips or fancy clips and strings simple and works what more do you need.

Why not try the imax?

Thanks for the suggestions but I went and bought an Abu flotation suit in John O'Briens sale anyway - much better value

and much warmer