johncodown wrote:Just to throw a spanner personaly I think pound for pound there's no other fish that can compare to a coalie on a fly rod

Aye John, Colin, a coley is a great fighter on a fly rod, very big difference when you hook one and youve been catching small pollack. Was thinkin more about the mack v sea trout thing, hard to compare them as fighters as they behave so differently (I can only relate to playing macs on spinner from the shore at this point).
The one thing I would say re mac/coley/trout is that when playing coley or mackerel the angler is more in control of the fight, on the other hand when hooked to a sea trout you have zero control about what happens next. In my experience they dont fight as other hard fighting fish do. They just go completely apeshit on the spot on the surface and far too often the fight is over before it even gets started because they throw the hook and you can almost hear them say 'wise up' as they swim off giving you a big middle finger.
I wish they would fight as other fish do, ie run about and dive instead of that frustrating churning on the surface. No other fish not even mullet (crazy but different fight again) do that virtually indescribable surface churning that a sea trout gets up to. They have my head turned these past few years, but Ive nearly lost hope in landing the better fish on spinner, I think I may just keep trying to get one to take a fly. Then there might be a chance.
The sea trout I fish for would be smaller than in other places, eg Strangford. To be honest I cant comment on what the fight of a sea trout larger than 2.5lb is like because I havent been able to keep them on the line for more than 5 seconds.
Cheers Brian, John, Colin.