Thu Nov 08, 2012 9:28 pm
Thu Nov 08, 2012 9:42 pm
Thu Nov 08, 2012 10:00 pm
myworldfishing wrote:Before I go into it I just want to point out that I am all for conservation.
But heres my take on it. This summer and last winter was the worse fishing Iv seen. Not just for Bass because Im an angler that will fish for al types of fish. But this year for allot of others as a whole has been good on so many levels, I have heard of a few record fish being landed and released, also a huge amount of specimens. Sure just look at the fishing in cork now with the painted ray which are also protected and like the Bass there is people taking ever single one they catch home with them.
How come no one on here ever complains about any other fish getting poached?.... Why is Bass the only focus of the Irish angler?
Why cant we write a letter complaing about the amount of cod, ray, mac, tuna and all the other types of fish that these super trawlers are taking from the sea.......
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Now that I have that bit out heres the next bit....
People are posting about the decline in Bass, but I know guys that are catching just as much as they did last year and also this summer was the coldest and wettest we have had for a very long time... Sure there still catching mac for feck sake...
So by all means write letters and do what ever we can to stop the trawlers getting their hands on the Bass but please can people stop blaming the decline in fish on anything other than natural causes....
Thu Nov 08, 2012 11:25 pm
Fri Nov 09, 2012 12:07 am
Fri Nov 09, 2012 12:14 am
myworldfishing wrote:Sure just look at the fishing in cork now with the painted ray which are also protected
Fri Nov 09, 2012 12:33 am
Crevan wrote:Thanks for the reply.
I was speaking from my own personal experience and that of the anglers I have fished with and met over the course of the season. They all share the same opinion on dwindling numbers...not just this year but over the years.
If you read my post again you'll see that I didnt blame the decline on anything.....I relayed different opinions which had been mooted by different anglers.
JimC wrote:myworldfishing wrote:Sure just look at the fishing in cork now with the painted ray which are also protected
Since when?
Fri Nov 09, 2012 12:35 am
Fri Nov 09, 2012 1:04 am
Fri Nov 09, 2012 10:09 am
roryodonnell wrote:I'd personally like to see the Bass take reduced to one from two. Also, making illegal (read highly publicised) the killing of ANY specimen fish.
Fri Nov 09, 2012 12:16 pm
Sun Nov 11, 2012 9:29 pm
Sun Nov 11, 2012 10:36 pm
lure fisher wrote:I hate to come across as being cynical but we as anglers have not really come together as a unit to protect our Bass. Irish Bass has done a little but there are simple things that individuals can do.
Every so often someone comes on here with another rally cry.I am reminded of the story of the boy who cried wolf.
I know that numbers are well down around the country and in waterford and wexford in particular, and there are a number of factors causing the decline. I think that recording of data is vital to track the numbers and attempt to reason out the causes.
The only person in Ireland with meaningful and accurate data appears to be Jim Hendrick.
We are all aware of the many factors that may be causing this decline. Lets hope its mostly weather related but I think deep down we are all fearing the worst.
In saying all of that, one major reason for the decline that is rarely mentioned is the "new" Bass fisherman who has no experience of the previous decline in numbers back in the 80's, has no idea of the fragility of the Bass stocks in Ireland, is easily excited, has caught a few fish on new top of the range japanese lures, and talks too much on all of the well known lure fishing forums.
In addition, a number of new Bass guides and sexy lure shops have, in the last couple of years, taken UK media star anglers to fish for our Bass and talk up the fishery to a level that is naive and careless in major UK fishing magazines and forums. These same media stars have no real idea about Bass fishing and what it means to find your own fish and understand the influences on Bass activity in a particular spot. They are seen as super stars because they catch a couple of fish. Im sure we all have a spot or two where we could bring someone, in reasonable conditions, who can cast a rod, who would catch a fish or two over a week of good tides and then make super sexy photos with a wide angle lens for a magazine and then call you a friend for a few weeks.
They talk of sexy fishing, sexy lures, sexy rods, LRF HRF and all of that shite, have over commercialised angling for Bass. To the point where we now have 2 angling competitions for Bass in Ireland that I am aware of. I now see gangs of lure fisherman marauding around locations, driving up and down beaches in 4x4's and looking cool. Do these guys think they are invisible to poachers etc? I swear Its getting like Montauk in some places.
The people involved know who they are so I wont bother mentioning names. There is nothing worse than men with big egos. I also think some Bass fishermen have no mirrors in their houses.
This has caused over fishing by anglers, and over poaching in certain well known Bass fishing locations for a few pieces of gold.
Commercial fishermen have seen all of this and the media and internet bullshit and are now convinced that there is a few bob to be made as they see their neighbours and brothers etc making a few quid from poaching Bass and want it legitimised.
A few good men foreseen this 5/6 years ago, and now unfortunately have seen it unfold in front of their eyes. So the next time you feel like mouthing off about a tiny piece of Bass fishing success on your blog or forum think of the Bass who have no egos but are just running the gauntlet of their world and remember that there are many vested interests watching all the time to make a quick buck and an ego boost.
Fair play to Pat and Henry for their efforts, two top guys and two top anglers who know the species and know what is going on in this country. Support them by completing their questionnaires and providing feedback and either rally around Irish Bass or unite in some constructive way but if we cant rally together to fight for Bass stocks could we even try next year to enjoy Bass fishing and keep mouths shut regarding the small number of successful missions that we may have in 2013.
Bass Fishing _ The Future......Have respect for the species, be careful talking about specific locations. If an angler gets lucky one day he might catch a few fish in a spot but if a poacher gets lucky he might take a few boxes from a spot.
I call on all of you to shut down your blogs and stay off them forums with the ego boosting stories that all sound the same, neither does anything for Irish Bass stocks.
I expect a few will be pe'ed of with this post but I reckon 90% of real Bass fisherman agree with me 100%.
Mon Nov 12, 2012 8:53 am
Mon Nov 12, 2012 2:02 pm
lure fisher wrote:The only person in Ireland with meaningful and accurate data appears to be Jim Hendrick.
lure fisher wrote:one major reason for the decline that is rarely mentioned is the "new" Bass fisherman who has no experience of the previous decline in numbers back in the 80's, has no idea of the fragility of the Bass stocks in Ireland, is easily excited, has caught a few fish on new top of the range japanese lures, and talks too much on all of the well known lure fishing forums.
lure fisher wrote: If an angler gets lucky one day he might catch a few fish in a spot but if a poacher gets lucky he might take a few boxes from a spot.
Mon Nov 12, 2012 4:05 pm
Mon Nov 12, 2012 4:36 pm
lure fisher wrote:Can you show me another source of meaningful and accurate data of Bass numbers which helps identify reasons for the decline?
lure fisher wrote:I see you like posting your catch numbers under your signature. I just wonder whats the point in that for example
Mon Nov 12, 2012 8:07 pm
lure fisher wrote:I hate to come across as being cynical but we as anglers have not really come together as a unit to protect our Bass. Totally agree with this.
Irish Bass has done a little but there are simple things that individuals can do. All suggestions are welcome
Every so often someone comes on here with another rally cry.I am reminded of the story of the boy who cried wolf.
I know that numbers are well down around the country and in waterford and wexford in particular, and there are a number of factors causing the decline. I think that recording of data is vital to track the numbers and attempt to reason out the causes. Agree with this which is the basis behind completing the Henry's Tackle surveys.
The only person in Ireland with meaningful and accurate data appears to be Jim Hendrick.
We are all aware of the many factors that may be causing this decline. Lets hope its mostly weather related but I think deep down we are all fearing the worst.
In saying all of that, one major reason for the decline that is rarely mentioned is the "new" Bass fisherman who has no experience of the previous decline in numbers back in the 80's, has no idea of the fragility of the Bass stocks in Ireland, is easily excited, has caught a few fish on new top of the range japanese lures, and talks too much on all of the well known lure fishing forums. Agreed to some extent but remember everyone was a "new" fisherman at some stage. Education could be a factor. Maybe part of the learning curve is to realise its not good to talk too much about catches.
In addition, a number of new Bass guides and sexy lure shops have, in the last couple of years, taken UK media star anglers to fish for our Bass and talk up the fishery to a level that is naive and careless in major UK fishing magazines and forums. These same media stars have no real idea about Bass fishing and what it means to find your own fish and understand the influences on Bass activity in a particular spot. They are seen as super stars because they catch a couple of fish. Im sure we all have a spot or two where we could bring someone, in reasonable conditions, who can cast a rod, who would catch a fish or two over a week of good tides and then make super sexy photos with a wide angle lens for a magazine and then call you a friend for a few weeks. Perhaps such "star anglers" as you call them could be used to our advantage in highlighting and educating the fragility of the bass stocks? Relevant information could be placed with in the fishing tackle shops?
They talk of sexy fishing, sexy lures, sexy rods, LRF HRF and all of that shite, have over commercialised angling for Bass. To the point where we now have 2 angling competitions for Bass in Ireland that I am aware of. I now see gangs of lure fisherman marauding around locations, driving up and down beaches in 4x4's and looking cool. Do these guys think they are invisible to poachers etc? I swear Its getting like Montauk in some places. Most poachers have been around for a while. Most dont need any help in finding where to lay down nets. Angling competitions, if run correctly, could also be used as a tool for educating anglers on the fragility of stocks and their importance.
The people involved know who they are so I wont bother mentioning names. There is nothing worse than men with big egos. I also think some Bass fishermen have no mirrors in their houses. Egos can be difficult to overcome but then so too are false perceptions of people.
This has caused over fishing by anglers, and over poaching in certain well known Bass fishing locations for a few pieces of gold.
Commercial fishermen have seen all of this and the media and internet bullshit and are now convinced that there is a few bob to be made as they see their neighbours and brothers etc making a few quid from poaching Bass and want it legitimised.
A few good men foreseen this 5/6 years ago, and now unfortunately have seen it unfold in front of their eyes. So the next time you feel like mouthing off about a tiny piece of Bass fishing success on your blog or forum think of the Bass who have no egos but are just running the gauntlet of their world and remember that there are many vested interests watching all the time to make a quick buck and an ego boost. I dont really have a problem with pictures on blogs provided they are discreet pics that give little away as regards location. Common sense usually prevails here but not always I grant you.
Fair play to Pat and Henry for their efforts, two top guys and two top anglers who know the species and know what is going on in this country. Support them by completing their questionnaires and providing feedback and either rally around Irish Bass or unite in some constructive way but if we cant rally together to fight for Bass stocks could we even try next year to enjoy Bass fishing and keep mouths shut regarding the small number of successful missions that we may have in 2013.
Bass Fishing _ The Future......Have respect for the species, be careful talking about specific locations. If an angler gets lucky one day he might catch a few fish in a spot but if a poacher gets lucky he might take a few boxes from a spot.
I call on all of you to shut down your blogs and stay off them forums with the ego boosting stories that all sound the same, neither does anything for Irish Bass stocks.
I expect a few will be pe'ed of with this post but I reckon 90% of real Bass fisherman agree with me 100%.
Mon Nov 12, 2012 8:47 pm