Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Mon May 23, 2011 1:07 pm

Stan wrote:Bass in the UK seem to have a different pattern to Irish Bass. There seems to be quite a bit of migration between France and England.

Huge shoals of fish can be found off the south coast of England and also in parts of France, such as le Harve, at certain times of the year.

On the other hand our Bass seem to be localised and do not seem to migrate. Thus if they are heavily fished they disappear quickly. Some older anglers will remember days around the south coast of Ireland in the 60's and 70's when Bass were very plentiful. Once they had commercial value and the commercial fishermen got at them they disappeared overnight. It was only when the commercial ban came back that they recovered and even then it took years. I remember years in the 80's and early 90's when a Bass was a sight to behold.

There should be NO SUPPORT for any type of commercial fishing for Bass here. One year of placing commercial fishing could wipe out the last few years of recovery.

Every rod caught Bass if worth far more than one caught in a commercially.

There should be no comparison between the Bass fisheries in the UK and here. We generally do not have huge shoals of migratory fish. Once Irish commercial fishermen target an area then it can be taken that the Bass will be lost and will not return. I have personally witnessed the destruction that commercial fishing can cause and hope that I never see it again.

By the way I very much doubt that there is any proof of a Bass in Ireland turning up in France. Is there any proof of this statement?

Well said, i think most anglers would be in full agreement with you.

fisher of bass wrote:its all ahead of us starting in the summer on hook and line' 2; 7meter boats as far as i know the owners were in the uk to see how is done.. Bim are backing them :?: its all to do with international quota trading :!:


Heard this last year aswell ! , is there any official proof that this is going ahead and in what area ?

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Mon May 23, 2011 3:11 pm

fisher of Bass wrote:its all ahead of us starting in the summer on hook and line' 2; 7meter boats as far as i know the owners were in the uk to see how is done.. Bim are backing them :?: its all to do with international quota trading :!:


Heard this last year aswell ! , is there any official proof that this is going ahead and in what area ?[/quote]


This is not true.
How could BIM ( a government body) experiment with something that illegal?
There is times when certain trail fisheries can be set up for information and scientific purposes by the use of a special derogation.
There is no such derogation for bass.

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Mon May 23, 2011 8:06 pm

Rampent Wreckfish wrote:
fisher of Bass wrote:its all ahead of us starting in the summer on hook and line' 2; 7meter boats as far as i know the owners were in the uk to see how is done.. Bim are backing them :?: its all to do with international quota trading :!:


Heard this last year aswell ! , is there any official proof that this is going ahead and in what area ?



This is not true.
How could BIM ( a government body) experiment with something that illegal?
There is times when certain trail fisheries can be set up for information and scientific purposes by the use of a special derogation.
There is no such derogation for Bass.[/quote]
area viij2,the sfpa,bim,ifi and the iswfp had a big meet in clonakity last week it will go a head on first week of july its been kept on the qt,it will be centrally controlled by the sfpa for 4 weeks,,i would be happy to be proved wrong,simon coveney is working with the fishermen on this one its all to do with the fishing communities around our coast,

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Mon May 23, 2011 8:36 pm

Fisher of bass,
i hope what your saying is incorrect.Just out of curiousity would your source be involved in the commercial sector.

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Mon May 23, 2011 10:17 pm

fisher of bass wrote:
Rampent Wreckfish wrote:
fisher of Bass wrote:its all ahead of us starting in the summer on hook and line' 2; 7meter boats as far as i know the owners were in the uk to see how is done.. Bim are backing them :?: its all to do with international quota trading :!:


Heard this last year aswell ! , is there any official proof that this is going ahead and in what area ?



This is not true.
How could BIM ( a government body) experiment with something that illegal?
There is times when certain trail fisheries can be set up for information and scientific purposes by the use of a special derogation.
There is no such derogation for Bass.

area viij2,the sfpa,bim,ifi and the iswfp had a big meet in clonakity last week it will go a head on first week of july its been kept on the qt,it will be centrally controlled by the sfpa for 4 weeks,,i would be happy to be proved wrong,simon coveney is working with the fishermen on this one its all to do with the fishing communities around our coast,[/quote]

This is Bad news if correct, and IMO its a big first step on the Commercial Ladder.

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Mon May 23, 2011 11:49 pm

We can say goodbye to bass angling if this goes ahead. What a pity!!

I would imagine that bass angling is worth a lot to the country. With proper management it could be worth a fortune. But hey when did our politicians manage anything properly!!!!

It might be worth while for some of the Cork anglers to approach Simon Coveny to see if these allegations are true.

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Wed May 25, 2011 10:02 pm

Tanglerat wrote:
roger de dodger wrote:i do agree it is the most envoiromently freindly form of fishing commercially for any spieces bar rod and line :|


errr, those fish were caught by rod and line, roger.


nope they are caught on long lines with hundreds of hooks ,thats line caught bass as apposed to net caught also they catch alot of other fish that go back alive in most cases :?

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Wed May 25, 2011 11:57 pm

roger de dodger wrote:
Tanglerat wrote:
roger de dodger wrote:i do agree it is the most envoiromently freindly form of fishing commercially for any spieces bar rod and line :|


errr, those fish were caught by rod and line, roger.


nope they are caught on long lines with hundreds of hooks ,thats line caught Bass as apposed to net caught also they catch alot of other fish that go back alive in most cases :?


Nope, NOT long-lined. Have a read:

http://www.linecaught.org.uk/index.php? ... Itemid=111

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Thu May 26, 2011 8:52 am

I have sent the following email to Simon Coveney. Maybe this will clarify matters.


Dear Mr Coveney,

Rumour has it on one of the angling websites that there was a meeting in Clonakilty of the various fisheries bodies allowing some commercial fishing for bass.

I enclose some quotes from this website below.

I find this hard to believe but would welcome news from your department as to whether this is true or not.


Yours faithfully,


Stan Ryan


Its all ahead of us starting in the summer on hook and line' 2; 7meter boats as far as i know the owners were in the uk to see how is done.. Bim are backing them its all to do with international quota trading


Heard this last year aswell ! , is there any official proof that this is going ahead and in what area ?[/quote]


This is not true.
How could BIM ( a government body) experiment with something that illegal?
There is times when certain trail fisheries can be set up for information and scientific purposes by the use of a special derogation.


There is no such derogation for Bass.[/quote]
area viij2,the sfpa,bim,ifi and the iswfp had a big meet in clonakity last week it will go a head on first week of july its been kept on the qt,it will be centrally controlled by the sfpa for 4 weeks,,i would be happy to be proved wrong,simon coveney is working with the fishermen on this one its all to do with the fishing communities around our coast,

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Fri May 27, 2011 9:45 pm

No reply from Minister Coveney yet. I would suggest that as many anglers as possible write to him ASAP. Put the pressure on and make our voices felt!!!

He may ignore 1 email but if enough of us are interested enough to email him we may get some reaction.

Please pass this on.

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Sat May 28, 2011 1:01 pm

Stan wrote:No reply from Minister Coveney yet. I would suggest that as many anglers as possible write to him ASAP. Put the pressure on and make our voices felt!!!

He may ignore 1 email but if enough of us are interested enough to email him we may get some reaction.

Please pass this on.

this is going ahead unfortunately

emails and letters have no effect. an affidavid outlining all details as you understand them is the only way as it must be rebutted or agreed with and if ignored then a tacit agreement is in place and proceedings can be brought in accordance with the law.
all politicians are short term thinkers so dont ever expect anything else.

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Sat May 28, 2011 1:07 pm

captain AHAB wrote:
this is going ahead unfortunately



Source?

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Sat May 28, 2011 1:21 pm

JimC wrote:
captain AHAB wrote:
this is going ahead unfortunately



Source?


i personally know quite a few inshore fishermen targetting shrimp, razor, crab and lobster have been organizing gear in the knowledge that this is going ahead and they tell me they have assurances from the ministers office that after the trial period itll be all systems go.

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Sat May 28, 2011 1:35 pm

Still too much hearsay for me. A trial period would surely be against the law and surely the law would have to be changed. Is there any precedent for something like that?
Could we have a trial period of hash smoking or drug taking?

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Sun May 29, 2011 8:48 pm

Come on lads lets see if we can make ourselves known to our minister for fisheries.

Send an email and find out If there will be ANY form of commercial bass fishing in Ireland. Pass this on to any angler or club that you know.

If we all sit back and let commercial fishing go ahead then we have only ourselves to blame!!

Volume=answers. Let Minister Coveneys at least know that you are concerned and he may answer.

BASS MUST BE PROTECTED

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Mon May 30, 2011 8:13 am

JimC wrote:Still too much hearsay for me. A trial period would surely be against the law and surely the law would have to be changed. Is there any precedent for something like that?
Could we have a trial period of hash smoking or drug taking?


Only if you land them right?

trial period could be C+R to assess feasibility....

Total speculation on my part tho

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Tue May 31, 2011 7:27 pm

I really hope this does not start, and that as many clubs and anglers in the areas can stand up and be counted in their opposition to it. I know just how hard it can be to locate bass in any numbers here in the north, and the angling system that has been in place in the republic for years has worked well to aid recovery of bass stocks, commercial rod and line fishing for them could undo a lot of the good work.
Maybe some of the Munster guys could get your conservation officer on the case to find out more, or the IFSA conservation officer Martin Howlin?

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Tue May 31, 2011 8:18 pm

Big Phil, seems like nobody else is willing to contact Simon Coveney. Anglers' strength is in numbers. The more of us that write to him the better. He has just ignored my email. :( :( If every angler writes to him we may get a response. If I am the only one then I will be classified as unimportant or a looney. Maybe I'm both!!! :D :D

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Tue May 31, 2011 8:58 pm

ive sent a couple of emails to him without reply, not even a generic one

Re: Commercial Line Bass Fishing In Southern England.

Tue May 31, 2011 9:50 pm

Have to say that I am disillusioned. I though that this man was genuine listening to him on the radio and TV. He seemed like a nice guy. I voted for FG . Has he not even got the courtesy to answer an email. Looks like I've been conned again!!! :twisted: :twisted: Quote " we will hit the ground running"..... wonder are they running backwards??


I still think that if enough anglers write to him that he will have to respond eventually.